Excavators 101. ISO vs. SAE Controls Explained for Cat Machines

Introduction

Caterpillar excavators are durable, capable machines used in construction, mining, forestry, infrastructure, and material handling applications. Manufactured by Caterpillar Inc., a leading brand in heavy equipment, Cat excavators range in size from compact to high tonnage machines for complex projects.

Excavators have a movable arm or stick with a bucket attached to the end and are designed for excavating and lifting material. They are essential on job sites for digging, trenching, demolition, landscaping, and more. Cat excavators are valued for their power, efficiency, safety features, and low operating costs.

ISO and SAE Standards

ISO (International Organization for Standardization) and SAE (Society of Automotive Engineers) are both organizations that develop and publish standards for various industries. When it comes to heavy equipment like excavators, the standards they have developed relate to the hydraulic systems and controls.

ISO standards specify the layout and function of hydraulic valve sections and controls in an excavator. For example, ISO 8643 establishes standard symbols and control diagrams for earth-moving machinery. ISO 10532 defines common terms and components used in hydraulic systems.

SAE J-1182 sets standards for hydraulic excavator control patterns. It specifies the location and operation of joysticks and pedals to control boom, arm, bucket, and travel functions. SAE aims to promote consistency between different manufacturers.

Both ISO and SAE standards serve to introduce common design principles. This allows operators to more easily switch between different brands of excavators. Manufacturers may choose to fully comply with ISO, SAE, or a blend of the two standards. Caterpillar excavators implement a combination of ISO and SAE controls. Understanding the standards helps operators quickly acclimate to any machine.

Hydraulic systems

Excavators rely on hydraulic systems to power and control machine movements. Hydraulic systems use pressurized hydraulic fluid to transfer force from a pump to hydraulic cylinders and motors. This creates the motion needed to operate the boom, arm, bucket, and travel functions on an excavator.

The hydraulic pump pressurizes the hydraulic fluid and sends it through valves to the appropriate cylinders or motors. The valves control the direction and flow rate of the fluid to achieve the desired motion. Double-acting hydraulic cylinders use pressurized fluid on both sides of the piston to provide force in both extend and retract directions.

Excavators have multiple hydraulic circuits – one for the boom and arm, one for the bucket and swing, one for propel motors, and more. The circuits allow independent control of each motion. Solenoid valves switch hydraulic fluid flows between circuits when the operator moves the control levers.

Hydraulic systems generate tremendous forces from relatively small pumps and cylinders. This allows excavators to lift, dig, swing, and propel heavy loads. Keeping hydraulic components in good condition is crucial for proper operation.

Source: https://lntcmb.com/hydraulic-excavator-working-principle/

Why standards matter

Standardization is critical when it comes to heavy equipment like excavators. As explained in an article on Weekly Safety, keeping equipment maintained is essential for preventing accidents and injuries. Standardization makes maintenance and repairs simpler and more efficient.

For excavators, having standardized hydraulic fittings and hoses is especially important. This allows parts to be interchanged easily without custom fabrication. According to PM Engineer, universal standards and codes enable construction teams to source replacement parts anywhere in the world. Without standardization, sourcing parts could become challenging.

Standardization also streamlines maintenance procedures. Mechanics familiar with ISO or SAE standards can service excavators from different manufacturers more easily. The standards provide a common framework. This improves safety by ensuring maintenance work meets accepted guidelines.

Caterpillar’s Approach to ISO and SAE Standards

Caterpillar offers both ISO and SAE control patterns on their excavators to accommodate different operator preferences and geographic regions.1 While SAE is more popular in North America, ISO is commonly used in Europe and other parts of the world. Caterpillar recognizes that operators trained on one control pattern may struggle switching to the other.

To meet diverse needs, Caterpillar does not take a one size fits all approach. They work closely with dealers to provide excavators with the optimal control pattern for each customer and application. Dealers can order machines set up for ISO or SAE based on the operator’s background. For large fleets with mixed operator experience, Cat can also customize models with both ISO and SAE joystick patterns. This flexibility helps make the transition between control standards easier on operators.

While accommodating both ISO and SAE, Caterpillar still aligns with industry standards in their hydraulic system designs. This ensures optimal performance, efficiency, and compatibility with attachments.2 Adhering to standards while offering flexible control patterns enables Cat excavators to meet diverse customer needs across the globe.

Operator considerations

How easily an operator can find replacement parts is an important consideration in the choice between ISO and SAE hydraulic systems. For Caterpillar excavators, using ISO certified components can make parts sourcing more straightforward. ISO 4413 and 4414 standards help ensure interchangeability and compatibility of hydraulic system parts from different manufacturers. This gives operators and maintenance teams more flexibility and convenience in sourcing spare parts locally or online, instead of relying solely on the OEM dealer network. SAE standards, while high quality, can present more difficulty finding cross-compatible components from other brands.

According to Brennan Inc., having a safe and reliable hydraulic system requires proper maintenance using quality replacement parts as needed. Following ISO standards supports this by facilitating access to parts from various suppliers that adhere to the same specifications.

Dealer Support

Caterpillar has an extensive network of local dealers who provide parts support for Cat excavators and other heavy equipment. Dealers keep a large inventory of parts available to get machines back up and running quickly. According to The Resilient Enterprise, Cat’s Dealer Parts Inventory Search system allows dealers to locate parts anywhere in the global network. This ensures parts can be sourced quickly when needed to minimize downtime.

Having parts available locally is essential for excavator uptime. Dealers stock high demand parts on-site while maintaining access to Caterpillar’s extensive inventory system. Technicians can quickly identify needed parts and have them delivered to the customer site. With a focus on availability, dealer support keeps Cat excavators running.

Parts sourcing

When it comes to sourcing replacement parts for excavators, interchangeability between ISO and SAE standards is an important consideration. Excavators built to ISO standards tend to have more interchangeable parts with other brands than those built to Caterpillar’s proprietary SAE controls.

For example, according to discussions on heavy equipment forums, buckets, attachments, and some hydraulic components may be interchangeable between brands like Komatsu, Hitachi, and Kobelco which use ISO controls (Source 1). However, Caterpillar excavators that use SAE controls tend to have less parts commonality with other brands.

This can make it easier and often less expensive to source replacement parts for excavators built to the more widely used ISO standard. When evaluating excavators, owners should consider the availability and interchangeability of parts if they plan to source components from third party suppliers.

Maintenance

Regular maintenance is critical for excavators to operate safely and efficiently. This involves routine inspections, fluid checks, filter changes, and component replacements as needed. Some key maintenance considerations related to hydraulic system standards include:

Using proper fluids – Be sure to use hydraulic fluids that meet the specifications and standards for the machine. For Cat excavators, this is often hydraulic oils that meet Caterpillar’s strict standards.

Inspecting hoses and seals – Routinely check hydraulic hoses, couplings, cylinders and other components for leaks, cracks, or damage. Address any issues immediately to prevent contamination or loss of fluid pressure.

Replacing filters – Change hydraulic fluid filters based on machine hours to remove contaminants. Use filters that meet the OEM specifications.

Breathers and vents – Keep breathers clean and inspect for blockages or damage. Contaminants can enter the hydraulic reservoir through clogged breathers.

Fluid sampling – Take periodic samples of hydraulic fluid to test viscosity, water content, and contaminants. This allows early diagnosis of issues before failure occurs.

Proper procedures – Follow manufacturer procedures for safely repairing, replacing or maintaining hydraulic components. Prevent contamination and use care when servicing high pressure systems.

With proper maintenance based on hydraulic standards and OEM guidelines, excavators can operate safely and productively.

Conclusion

When it comes to Cat excavators, both ISO and SAE standard hydraulic systems offer advantages and disadvantages. ISO hydraulic systems tend to have higher hydraulic pressures, allowing for more hydraulic power and potentially more productivity. However, ISO systems may be less fuel efficient and have higher lifecycle costs. SAE systems aim for better fuel efficiency and lower operating costs, but may sacrifice some productivity.

Caterpillar offers both ISO and SAE standard excavators to meet different customer needs. ISO models like the 336 are designed for high production applications, while SAE models like the 320 target lower fuel consumption. Operators should understand the differences between the two standards and pick the system that best fits their work requirements. Proper maintenance and service from Cat dealers can maximize uptime and performance no matter which standard you choose.

The most important thing is choosing the excavator that allows operators to work efficiently and safely. With expertise from Caterpillar in designing both ISO and SAE hydraulic systems, you can be confident you’ll get a reliable, productive machine.

Scroll to Top