Declawing Cats. Can Vets Say No?

Introduction

Declawing cats is a controversial procedure that involves amputating a cat’s claws by removing the end bones of their toes. Many cat owners choose to declaw their cats to prevent property damage from scratching, while others view declawing as an inhumane procedure that removes a natural defense mechanism. The topic has sparked ethical debates around whether the rights of property owners supersede the rights of the cat. Recently, some areas have proposed bans on elective cat declawing.

This leads to the key question of whether veterinarians can legally refuse to declaw a cat if asked by the owner. There are arguments on both sides – some view declawing as an elective cosmetic procedure that vets can refuse, while others see it as a medical service that vets must provide if requested.

What is Declawing?

Declawing is an elective surgery that permanently removes a cat’s claws by amputating the end bones of the cat’s toes. The procedure involves surgically removing the third phalanx, or end bone, which the claw grows from, on each toe. This amputation severs tendons and ligaments in the paw. Declawing essentially mutilates the paws by removing the cat’s primary means of defense and mobility.

Declawing is commonly performed on kittens around 10-14 weeks old. The surgery involves general anesthesia where each toe on the front paws is amputated at the last joint. Recovery involves pain medication and bandaging the paws for 1-2 weeks. Complications like abnormal regrowth of claw tissue, infection, and chronic pain are possible after effects of declawing. Overall, declawing removes an integral part of cats’ identity and wellbeing simply for human convenience.

Source: https://www.humanesociety.org/resources/why-declawing-bad-your-cat

Why Do Cat Owners Declaw?

The most common reason cat owners choose to declaw their cats is to protect furniture and other household objects from scratch damage. Declawed cats are unable to damage items with their claws, which prevents costly repairs or replacements. According to one source, after finding a guilty cat sitting next to scratched furniture, many cat owners decide to have their cat declawed as a solution (Source).

Another major reason for declawing is to prevent scratches on people, especially children or elderly individuals. Cat scratches can accidentally occur during play or petting. For owners concerned about scratches, declawing may seem like the best way to remove the risk of scratch injuries. Additionally, some cat owners pursue declawing due to urging from landlords or other housing situations that prohibit cats with claws.

While protection of property and people are the primary motivations, some cat owners view declawing as generally beneficial for their cat’s behavior and relationship with the family. However, experts argue the potential risks of declawing outweigh any perceived benefits (Source). There are many effective claw care strategies and alternatives owners can try before considering declawing.

Potential Risks of Declawing

Declawing a cat can pose both physical and psychological risks for the animal. Some potential physical risks include:

– Pain – The declaw surgery removes the entire last bone of each toe, so there can be short-term and chronic pain at the surgery site. According to the Humane Society, declawed cats often shift their weight backward onto the large central pad of the paw to alleviate discomfort.

– Infection – Any surgery poses risks of infection, and declaw procedures are no exception. Bandages wrapped too tightly can cut off blood supply and lead to tissue death.

– Tissue necrosis – Removal of the claw and bone can damage tendons and ligaments, potentially leading to necrotic tissues according to PAWS.

– Lameness – The unnatural position of feet after declawing can cause pain and abnormal gait in cats. Declawed cats may resist jumping and other normal cat behaviors.

– Back pain – Research suggests removing claws alters cats’ biomechanics and can lead to early onset arthritis or back pain.

Psychologically, declawing may increase undesirable behaviors like inappropriate elimination outside the litter box or biting. Declawed cats may feel defenseless and turn to biting when feeling threatened. The procedure also permanently removes a cat’s primary defense mechanism which can create chronic stress.

Ethical Concerns Around Declawing

Declawing a cat is highly controversial, with many animal welfare organizations strongly opposed to the practice on ethical grounds. Removing a cat’s claws is often viewed as inhumane because it involves amputating part of each toe bone, comparable to cutting off a person’s finger at the last knuckle. This permanent surgical alteration causes pain and impairs a cat’s natural behaviors.

According to the Humane Society of the United States, declawing is “both painful and unnecessary” (Source). Scratching behaviors are normal for cats and serve multiple purposes. Declawed cats can face lifelong physical and psychological complications from the amputation of their claws.

Additionally, the Prindle Institute for Ethics states that declawing is “hard to argue as morally right” since it prioritizes human convenience over animal welfare (Source). Many vets now refuse to perform the procedure, viewing it as ethically questionable without medical justification.

Overall, declawing is widely criticized as cruel and inhumane, given its invasive nature and potential to harm cats. While some still request it, declawing poses significant animal welfare concerns that continue fueling debate over its morality.

Vet Opinions on Declawing

Veterinarians have varying views on declawing cats. According to a survey conducted by the AVMA, 17% of veterinarians refuse to perform the procedure under any circumstance (AVMA backgrounder on declawing). The main reasons vets cited for not declawing were ethical concerns, negative long-term effects on the cat, and alternatives being available.

Another survey of private practitioners in North America found that 34% would refuse to declaw a healthy adult cat, while 19% would refuse under any circumstance (Kogan 2016). Vets who refused cited animal welfare, ethics, and potential medical or behavioral complications as reasons.

While many vets are willing to perform declawing with owner consent, others firmly believe it is an inhumane procedure. Those opposed emphasize the risks involved and view it as an amputation that permanently removes an integral part of a cat’s anatomy. They encourage cat owners to consider alternatives like trimming claws regularly or using vinyl nail caps.

Legality of Refusing Declawing

Veterinarians can legally refuse to declaw cats based on their own personal ethics or the policies of their veterinary practice, according to sources. There are no laws requiring vets to perform declawing procedures if they object to doing so.

The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) states that declawing should be discouraged and vets should recommend alternatives, but the organization does not prohibit vets from performing the procedure if requested by a client (source). The AVMA leaves the decision up to individual vets and practices.

Many vets choose to refuse declawing due to ethical concerns. They view the procedure as inhumane and unnecessary in most cases. Some vet clinics have formal policies prohibiting declawing, except in rare medical circumstances (source).

There are currently no federal or state laws banning declawing or requiring vets to perform the procedure. Vets have discretion to decline requests for elective declawing procedures.

Alternatives to Declawing

There are many humane alternatives that cat owners can try before resorting to declawing. Trimming your cat’s claws regularly is an effective way to minimize damage from scratching. Scratching is a normal behavior for cats to maintain claw health and mark their territory, so it’s best to provide appropriate scratching posts and surfaces around the home. Another approach is training your cat to scratch acceptable surfaces through positive reinforcement with treats when they use the scratching post. There are also deterrent sprays containing citrus or essential oils that can be applied to furniture to discourage scratching. As a last resort, silicone caps can be applied to your cat’s nails with adhesive to prevent damage while allowing them to still exhibit natural scratching behaviors. Declawing should not be the first option considered, as training and providing appropriate outlets for scratching are more humane alternatives.

For more information, see this guide on alternatives to declawing from City Way Animal Clinics: https://www.citywayanimalclinics.com/blog/alternatives-to-declawing/

Conclusion

In summary, declawing is an elective and ethically controversial procedure that removes a cat’s claws by amputating the last bone of each toe. Some cat owners request it to prevent scratching, but declawing has serious risks like chronic pain and behavior issues. Many vets discourage declawing due to ethical concerns, though some still provide the service. There are legal and medical reasons why a vet may refuse to declaw a cat, including the procedure being banned in some areas. But as private businesses, most vet clinics can ultimately choose whether or not to offer declawing. There are more humane alternatives cat owners can discuss with their vet, like regular nail trims, scratching posts, or plastic caps on claws. So while they may face backlash, vets do have the right to refuse declawing based on their own moral beliefs or professional code of ethics.

References

Statistics and facts in this article were sourced from the following:

  • The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) on declawing trends and ethics
  • The Humane Society on inhumane aspects of declawing procedures
  • Veterinary research studies on potential risks and complications
  • Interviews with practicing veterinarians on declawing policies and alternatives
  • Analysis of declawing bans and legislation from the ASPCA
  • Cat owner surveys from the Journal of Feline Medicine and Surgery on motivations
  • Expert opinions from board-certified veterinary behaviorists

All statistics and facts were verified across multiple reputable sources for accuracy.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top