How Traumatic Is Declawing A Cat?

Introduction

Declawing a cat involves amputating the end bones of a cat’s toes. While once a common practice, declawing has become very controversial in recent years. Many vets and animal welfare organizations now discourage or condemn the procedure due to evidence of short-term and long-term negative impacts on cats. However, some vets still defend declawing as an option in certain circumstances. There is an ongoing debate around whether declawing should be banned entirely. This article will examine the procedure itself as well as the physical, psychological, and ethical impacts in order to understand how traumatic declawing truly is for cats.

Research sources:
https://www.somerset-kentucky.com/news/local_news/vet-breaks-down-declawing-controversy-outlines-alternatives-for-cat-owners/article_b8a9586b-2aed-585f-ace3-a27af409c33f.html

Physical Effects

Declawing a cat is an extremely traumatic and painful procedure that can lead to severe physical effects. The surgery involves amputating the last bone of each toe, which contains nerves, ligaments, and tendons. This causes significant pain both during recovery and long-term.

According to the Human Society of the United States (source), declawing often leads to complications such as:

  • Chronic pain in the paws or back from tendon strain
  • Infection or tissue necrosis from poor surgery procedures
  • Improper healing and nerve damage
  • Lameness or impaired balance from tendon contracture

The amputation of the toe bone exposes sensitive nerve endings that can make the paws extremely painful, especially when walking or jumping. This pain can persist long-term. Declawed cats often shift their weight onto other legs, leading to strain and back pain (source). The surgery also permanently removes the cat’s primary defense mechanism, leaving them unable to climb, scratch, or escape if needed.

Psychological Effects

Declawing a cat can have profound psychological effects on the cat. Removing their claws, which are their primary defense mechanism, can make cats feel vulnerable and anxious. This vulnerability can lead to long-term behavioral problems such as increased biting and avoiding the litter box.

According to the SPCA, declawed cats often feel a loss of self-confidence after the procedure (SPCA). Without their main form of defense, declawed cats can become fearful, withdrawn, and even aggressive. This anxiety and fearfulness often presents as biting behavior, since the cat no longer has claws to defend itself.

Increased litter box avoidance is another common psychological effect in declawed cats. According to Idyllic Paws, declawed cats may associate the litter box with pain after the declawing surgery, leading them to stop using the litter box altogether (Idyllic Paws). This avoidance can persist long-term, resulting in cats urinating or defecating outside of the litter box.

The psychological trauma of declawing can have lifelong impacts on a cat’s comfort and behavior. Removing a cat’s main defense against threats understandably creates anxiety, fear, and insecurity in the cat, often resulting in problematic behaviors like biting and litter box avoidance.

Long-term Impacts

Declawing a cat can lead to chronic long-term health issues beyond the initial recovery period. According to the PetMD article “5 Negative Side Effects of Declawing Cats” (https://www.petmd.com/cat/general-health/negative-side-effects-of-declawing-cats), declawed cats are at higher risk of developing painful arthritis and lameness in their paws due to abnormal weight distribution after the surgery. The declawing procedure removes the end bones of the cat’s digits, severing ligaments and tendons. This can cause chronic pain similar to phantom limb pain in humans. According to the Human Society article “Why declawing is bad for your cat” (https://www.humanesociety.org/resources/why-declawing-bad-your-cat), lameness and changes in gait from declawing may become apparent years after the initial surgery as arthritis sets in. Some declawed cats shift their weight onto their hindlegs to avoid pain in their front paws, which can lead to overuse injuries. The lifelong impacts of declawing demonstrate why the procedure is inhumane and risky for feline health.

Alternatives to Declawing

Declawing cats is an unnecessary procedure. There are many humane and effective alternatives to permanently removing a cat’s claws that will protect your home and furniture.

One alternative is regular nail trimming. Trimming your cat’s nails every 1-2 weeks will blunt the nails and make them less damaging if the cat scratches. Introduce nail trims slowly with positive reinforcement to make it a pleasant experience for your cat. Ask your veterinarian to show you the proper technique for nail trimming.1

Providing adequate scratching surfaces is another alternative. Scratching posts made of sisal, cardboard, or wood allow cats to engage in normal scratching behavior. Place posts near furniture you want to protect. Consider multiple posts of different textures around your home. Praise your cat for using the scratching posts to encourage appropriate scratching.2

Nail caps like Soft Paws are plastic caps that cover the cat’s nails to prevent damage. The caps fall off as the nails shed and need to be replaced every 4-6 weeks. Proper application ensures nail caps are comfortable for the cat.3 With training, nail trims, and scratching posts, nail caps may be unnecessary.

Medical Perspectives

Veterinary medical associations have nuanced positions on declawing that take into account medical ethics, cat welfare, and client education. The American Veterinary Medical Association (AVMA) states that declawing should be discouraged as an elective procedure, but recognizes it may be needed in some cases for medical or behavioral reasons, and ultimately leaves the decision up to the veterinarian’s professional judgement (AVMA). The AVMA encourages alternatives like trimming claws or using scratching posts, but does not condemn declawing outright. The American Association of Feline Practitioners (AAFP) takes a firmer stance against routine declawing, stating veterinarians should educate clients on alternatives and only declaw as a last resort for medical or behavioral issues (AAFP).

These positions aim to balance cat welfare, client relationships, and professional autonomy. The veterinary profession acknowledges declawing has negative effects, but stops short of banning the practice since situations may exist where it is deemed necessary. Overall, vet associations encourage lifestyle adjustments, discourage elective declawing, but defer final decisions to vets’ clinical judgement.

Legal Status

Declawing cats is banned or considered animal cruelty in over 42 countries, including most of Europe, Australia, Brazil, Israel, and New Zealand. There are growing restrictions on declawing within the United States as well. Several U.S. cities have banned the practice, including Denver, Los Angeles, San Francisco, Pittsburgh, and St. Louis. New York was the first U.S. state to ban declawing in 2019, except for medical necessity confirmed by a licensed veterinarian. As of 2023, declawing is also fully banned in Maryland and Rhode Island.

According to https://www.air1.com/news/us-and-world/more-states-ban-declawing-of-cats-45298, Washington D.C. recently banned declawing, while Michigan is in the process of enacting a statewide ban. Several other states are considering anti-declawing legislation as well. Though not yet illegal everywhere, public opposition to declawing is growing in light of animal cruelty concerns.

Owner Decisions

Many cat owners consider declawing because they are worried about damage to furniture or scratches on people, especially children. However, declawing should not be treated as an optional cosmetic procedure or an easy fix. Removing a cat’s claws changes their anatomy and has lifelong impacts on the animal. As pet owners, we have an ethical responsibility to make informed choices that protect the wellbeing of the animals in our care. When adopting any pet, claws are simply part of the package. There are many effective alternatives to declawing that allow cat owners to redirect scratching behaviors in a humane way. With proper training, routine nail trims, and scratching posts, cats can satisfy their natural urge to scratch without damaging furniture. Pet owners should view declawing as an absolute last resort, if all other options have failed. https://www.popsci.com/declaw-your-cat/ Most vets argue that the potential risks of declawing outweigh any benefits, and many areas have banned the practice due to animal welfare concerns. While scratching can be frustrating, it’s important to remember that this is normal cat behavior, not a malicious act or a sign of aggression. As responsible pet parents, we must adapt our homes and teach appropriate scratching habits to keep cats happy, healthy, and claw-intact.

Ethical Considerations

Declawing cats raises significant ethical concerns, primarily regarding animal cruelty. Declawing involves amputating the last bone of each toe, which is an incredibly painful procedure for the cat (The Humane Society). Many view declawing as an act of mutilation done solely for the convenience of the owner without any medical justification. It permanently removes the cat’s main defense mechanism, leaving them vulnerable.

Additionally, declawing is condemned as animal cruelty and is illegal in many parts of the world, including most European countries (Prindle Institute). Even where it is legal, declawing raises moral objections about unnecessary harm inflicted on animals for non-essential reasons. While some argue declawing prevents furniture damage, most view this as insufficient justification to amputate parts of a cat’s paws.

The ethical implications have led veterinary associations and animal welfare groups to strongly oppose routine declawing except for rare medical necessity. There is an ethical responsibility to avoid unnecessary harm to animals under our care. Most experts advise cat owners to pursue humane alternatives like trimming claws or training instead.

Conclusion

The evidence presented clearly shows that declawing involves risks and harm. While some cat owners pursue it with what they think are good intentions, declawing goes against a cat’s natural behaviors and needs. Removing the claws changes how cats move and can cause chronic pain and other issues. This invasive surgery should be avoided, as there are more humane alternatives to prevent unwanted scratching. Cats use their claws for balance, stretching, and defense – declawing takes away important abilities. Since declawing is so traumatic and detrimental to cat health and welfare, owners should reconsider this procedure. There are effective options available to redirect scratching behavior that do not involve permanent surgery. The risks outweigh any perceived benefits, so it’s best for owners to pursue other solutions. Declawing is inhumane and unnecessary. With more information and better choices, hopefully fewer cats will undergo this traumatic and harmful amputation.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top