Declawing Your Cat. Is There an Age Limit?

Introduction

Declawing is a controversial procedure that involves surgically removing a cat’s claws by amputating the end bones of the cat’s toes. Many veterinarians and animal welfare groups strongly oppose declawing, saying it is inhumane and can lead to future medical and behavioral problems in cats. However, some cat owners believe declawing is necessary to prevent damage to furniture, while others may request it if adopting a cat that will be around immunocompromised people who could suffer serious infections from scratches. Due to concerns over declawing, an increasing number of countries and local jurisdictions have banned the practice or imposed age limits, allowing declawing only under certain circumstances.

What is Declawing?

Declawing is the surgical amputation of a cat’s claws by removing the last bone of each toe of their paws. The procedure involves amputating the distal phalanx or third phalanx bone of each toe, which is closely adhered to the claw ([source]). Declawing is not just trimming the claws down to the quick; it is the complete removal of the claw by surgically cutting off each toe at the first knuckle joint ([source]).

The anatomy of a cat’s paw consists of bones called phalanges. There are three phalanges in each digit – P1, P2, and P3. Declawing removes the entire P3 phalanx bone along with the claw. This is an amputation and equates to cutting off a person’s finger at the first knuckle joint ([source]).

Reasons for Declawing

The two main reasons cat owners choose to declaw their cats are to prevent damage to furniture and to avoid injury from scratches 1. Declawing removes the cat’s claws so they cannot scratch furniture, carpeting, drapes, and other household items. For some owners, protecting their home furnishings is important enough to justify declawing. Scratching is a natural behavior for cats, allowing them to mark their territory and sharpen their claws. So declawing may be seen as a preventative measure.

Another major reason for declawing is to prevent scratches, both accidental and aggressive, that can cause injury. Some owners declaw kittens early on so they will not develop scratching behaviors. Elderly individuals or families with small children may choose to declaw an adult cat due to concerns over scratches. Aggressive cats may be declawed in an attempt to reduce biting and scratching during handling. So while controversial, declawing is sometimes done with the intent of protecting people from harm.

Negative Effects of Declawing

Declawing can lead to severe negative physical and psychological side effects for cats. According to the Humane Society of the United States, declawing causes lifelong pain, infection, tissue necrosis, lameness, and back pain (Source). The abnormal sitting and ambulating caused by declawing changes a cat’s center of gravity and leads to strained joints and muscles in the legs and back from overcompensating. Declawed cats are also prone to develop painful bone spurs on their amputated toe bones from improper healing and regrowth. Nerve damage from the declaw surgery can also lead to chronic pain.

In addition to physical problems, declawing increases the risk of behavioral issues in cats. Studies show an increase in undesirable behaviors like biting, inappropriate urination or defecation, and aggression after being declawed. According to PetMD, declawing is thought to remove a cat’s primary defense mechanism, causing increased stress, anxiety, and frustration (Source). The chronic pain from declawing combined with defensive stress is believed to contribute to these problematic behaviors.

Declawing Bans

Many countries and some states in the U.S. have banned the practice of declawing cats due to animal cruelty concerns. Declawing a cat is illegal in Australia, Austria, Belgium, Bosnia and Herzegovina, Brazil, Bulgaria, Cyprus, the Czech Republic, Denmark, Estonia, Finland, France, Germany, Greece, Iceland, Ireland, Israel, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Malta, the Netherlands, New Zealand, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Scotland, Serbia, Slovenia, Sweden, Switzerland, Turkey, and England (PETA).

In the United States, declawing is banned in many cities including Austin, Texas; Denver, Colorado; Los Angeles, California; San Francisco, California; and St. Louis, Missouri. The states of New York and New Jersey have also banned the declawing of cats except for medical necessity (Alley Cat Allies). Several other states are considering legislation to ban elective declawing. The bans aim to prevent unnecessary pain and suffering for cats from undergoing amputation of their toes just to protect furniture.

Age Limits for Declawing

Veterinarians and animal welfare organizations typically recommend declawing at a young age, if at all. The ideal age range is between 3 and 6 months old according to Advanced Pet Vet. [1] Cats at this age recover more quickly from surgery and may experience less trauma compared to older cats. [2]

Declawing older adult cats, especially over 1 year old, is not recommended. The surgery tends to be more invasive and recovery takes longer the older the cat is. There is also an increased risk of long-term negative effects like pain and behavior issues in adult cats after being declawed. [3]

Most vets suggest combining declawing with spay/neuter surgery, which is often done around 5-6 months old. This allows the cat to only undergo anesthesia once. Overall, kittens have the best outcomes when declawed between 3-6 months old versus older adult cats.

Veterinarian Recommendations

Most veterinarians recommend declawing a cat between 3 and 6 months of age. According to the AVMA, this age range allows kittens to recover quickly with less trauma compared to older cats[1]. Declawing at the time of spay/neuter surgeries is also commonly suggested, as the cat is already under anesthesia. The 3-6 month age range lines up with typical spay/neuter timeframes[2]. Overall, veterinarians view 3-6 months as an ideal declawing window that balances minimized trauma with procedure effectiveness.

Alternatives to Declawing

Instead of declawing, there are several humane alternatives cat owners can try to prevent scratching furniture or aggression with claws. Here are some of the top alternatives according to veterinarians and animal welfare organizations:

Regular nail trimming – Trimming a cat’s nails every 1-2 weeks can help blunt the claws so they do less damage when scratching. Special cat nail trimmers make it easy for owners to trim claws safely at home.

Nail caps – Nail caps like Soft Paws are plastic sheaths that fit over the cat’s claws to prevent scratching without removing the claws. The caps fall off as the nail grows out and need to be replaced every 4-6 weeks.

Cat scratching posts and pads – Providing appropriate scratching posts, cardboard scratchers, and scratching pads can give cats an outlet for their natural scratching instinct. Catnip or treats can encourage cats to use the scratchers.

Training – With positive reinforcement training, owners can redirect cats to scratch acceptable surfaces. Praising cats and giving treats when they use scratching posts trains them to scratch in desired areas.

Pheromone diffusers – Synthetic pheromones like Feliway can curb aggressive scratching and calm stressed cats. The pheromones are dispersed around the house and help relax cats.

Adoption Policies

Many animal shelters and rescue organizations have adoption policies that prohibit future declawing of adopted cats. These policies aim to reduce the number of cats undergoing the declawing procedure, which is viewed as inhumane by many animal welfare groups.

For example, Cat Adoption Team in Oregon includes the following clause in their adoption contract: “Declawing CAT asks adopters not to declaw adopted cats. Your adoption counselor can provide information about the detriments of declawing, humane alternatives, and medical/behavioral services that can prevent destructive scratching.” [1]

Shelters use the adoption screening process to educate potential adopters about declawing and inform them of the policy. If adopters later violate the contract by having the cat declawed, some shelters will refuse to allow that person to adopt again. However, enforcement of the policy can be challenging once the cat is in its new home.

Conclusion

In summary, declawing is a controversial procedure that permanently removes a cat’s claws by amputating the last bone of each toe. While some pet owners choose to declaw to protect furniture, the surgery can lead to pain, infection, and behavior changes in cats. Many veterinarians argue that declawing should only be a last resort, and several countries have banned the procedure as inhumane.

In the United States, there is no federal law prohibiting declawing, but some states and cities have implemented bans or age restrictions, often limiting elective declawing to cats under 4 months old. Before considering declawing, pet owners should explore alternatives like regular nail trims, scratching posts, or soft plastic caps called nail caps. Adopting cats already declawed or with a pre-existing medical condition requiring the surgery is another option.

With proper training, exercise, and outlets for natural scratching behavior, declawing is unnecessary. Cats use their claws for balance, exercise, and territory marking. Removing them permanently should not be taken lightly. With compassion and patience, pet owners can maintain both their cat’s claws and their furniture.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top