Cheap vs Expensive Cat Food. What’s the Real Difference and Why it Matters


Pet owners want the best for their furry companions. But with the wide range of cat food options and prices on the market, many wonder if pricier brands are actually any better than cheaper alternatives. Is that fancy feast really worth the extra cost? This article will examine the key differences between cheap and expensive cat foods when it comes to ingredients, nutrition, manufacturing, texture, veterinarian recommendations, health impacts, and environmental considerations. We’ll aim to help cat owners determine if premium pet foods are worth the price tag or if budget options can still provide good nutrition. Stick around to learn the pros and cons of both so you can make the best decision for your feline friend’s needs and your wallet.

Ingredient Quality

There are significant differences in the quality of ingredients between cheap and expensive cat foods. Expensive cat foods generally contain more high-quality protein from whole meat sources like chicken, beef, and fish. Cheap cat foods often rely more on meat by-products, which may include parts like bones, blood, intestines, lungs, spleen, kidneys, brain, liver, and stomach contents.

Protein sources are very important for cats since they are obligate carnivores and require high levels of protein in their diet. According to Cheapism, expensive cat foods get protein from fresh meats while cheap foods rely more on by-products and plant-based proteins like corn and soy. Cheap foods also tend to have more carbohydrate fillers like corn, wheat, and rice.

When it comes to fat sources, expensive cat foods utilize higher quality fats from animal sources while cheap cat foods contain more plant-based fats. Animal fats provide fatty acids like omega-3s which are essential for skin and coat health.

Overall, the ingredient quality of expensive cat foods is superior, with more protein from whole meat sources and better fat sources. Cheap cat foods rely heavily on by-products, plant proteins, and carbohydrate fillers.

Nutritional Value

There are some key differences in the nutritional value between cheap and expensive cat foods. Expensive cat foods tend to have higher quality sources of protein, fats, and carbohydrates. According to one source, expensive brands will use meat or fish ingredients as the first 2-3 ingredients, whereas cheaper brands often use plant proteins and fillers higher up on the list (Source).

The protein in pricier cat foods comes from whole meats like chicken, salmon, or turkey. Cheaper brands may use plant proteins like corn gluten meal or meat by-products. Cats are obligate carnivores and do best on high protein diets with quality animal-based proteins. The fat sources also differ, with expensive foods using animal fats while cheap foods rely more on plant oils.

When it comes to carbs, expensive cat foods tend to have fewer fillers like corn, wheat, soy, etc. They may use whole grains like brown rice. Too many carbs from plants can lead to obesity and diabetes in cats. Overall, the better nutrition from high-end cat foods leads to better health outcomes. Cats fed food with optimal protein, fat, and carbs will have shinier coats, more energy, and reduced risk of issues like urinary tract infections (Source).

Manufacturing Process

There are important differences in the manufacturing processes for cheap vs. expensive cat food. Cheap cat foods often cut corners when it comes to quality control and meeting high safety standards.

Expensive brands invest more resources into rigorous quality control at every stage of production. They carefully monitor for contamination, ensure precise nutritional formulations, and test finished products for quality and safety. According to, expensive brands often have their own manufacturing facilities with strict protocols. Cheap brands are more likely to contract third-party manufacturers, with less oversight into the process.

When it comes to safety, premium brands meet stricter standards that go beyond the minimum FDA requirements. They focus on sourcing high-quality ingredients and controlling pathogens like salmonella. Cheaper brands adhere to basic FDA regulations but may take fewer extra precautions. There is a greater risk of unsafe ingredients or contamination issues with cheap cat food.

In summary, the more expensive manufacturing process of premium brands results in higher quality control and safer standards compared to cheap cat foods.

Texture and Palatability

The texture and palatability of cat food can vary significantly between cheap and expensive options. Cheap cat foods often contain more fillers and by-products, giving the food a gritty, dry texture that is less palatable to cats. Pieces are often uniform in size and shape. Expensive cat foods focus more on actual meat ingredients, resulting in softer, meatier pieces of varying shapes and sizes that cats find more enticing. The sauces and gravies in expensive wet foods also tend to be thicker and richer.

These textural differences directly impact the food’s palatability – a measure of how tasty and appetizing it is to cats. Studies have shown cats prefer the aroma, texture, and flavor of certain protein-rich meats over plant-based ingredients (Source 1). The lower protein content of cheap foods leads many cats to eat only when extremely hungry, whereas they are eager to eat smaller meals of the expensive food. Owners report cats eating expensive food more readily and with greater enthusiasm. However, some cats may still prefer certain affordable foods, especially if that’s what they’re accustomed to.

Price Differences

One main difference between cheap and expensive cat food is the cost per pound or per calorie. Cheap cat foods typically cost $0.60 to $1 per pound, while premium foods cost $2 to $4 per pound. When looking at cost per calorie, cheap foods are around $0.25 per 100 calories, while premium foods are $0.40 to $1 per 100 calories.

There are several reasons why premium cat foods have a higher price tag than their cheap counterparts:

  • Premium foods use higher quality ingredients like real meat, fruits, vegetables, and whole grains. These cost more than the animal by-products and fillers used in cheap foods.
  • Premium brands invest in extensive research and testing to formulate recipes that meet cats’ nutritional needs. This increases production costs.
  • Manufacturing premium food requires higher levels of quality control and safety procedures. This also drives up costs.
  • Premium pet food brands spend more on packaging and marketing to convey the quality of their products. These expenses get passed onto the consumer.

In the end, pet owners must decide if the potential health benefits of premium cat food are worth the extra cost compared to cheap alternatives.

Veterinarian Recommendations

Veterinarians generally recommend avoiding the cheapest cat foods, as they often lack proper nutrition and can lead to health problems down the road. However, vets also caution cat owners not to assume the most expensive food is automatically the healthiest option.

According to veterinarian Dr. Katy Nelson, “you get what you pay for to a certain extent when it comes to pet food. The very cheap brands often cut corners on quality and nutrition.” She recommends looking for foods with meat as the first ingredient, avoiding too many fillers like corn and wheat, and making sure the food is formulated to meet nutritional standards set by the Association of American Feed Control Officials (AAFCO) (source).

However, many vets say paying more doesn’t always mean higher quality nutrition. “As you move up in price, the quality of the ingredients improves, but at a certain point you actually just start paying for marketing and fancy packaging,” says veterinarian Dr. Gary Richter (source). He cautions against “falling into the trap of thinking you aren’t feeding your cat high quality food unless you are spending a lot.”

The key is reading the label carefully, consulting with your veterinarian, and selecting a food formulated for your cat’s age and specific dietary needs. Monitoring your cat’s health and energy on a food can help determine if it’s a good nutritional match.

Health Impacts

There are a number of health differences between cats fed cheap food versus high quality cat food. Cats fed a cheap diet high in carbohydrates and fillers are more likely to become overweight or obese, according to veterinarians. This puts them at higher risk for diabetes, arthritis, heart disease and other weight-related conditions (Source).

High quality cat foods with more protein and fat can help cats maintain a healthy weight and body condition. The nutrients in premium foods also contribute to shinier coats, healthier skin, and improved digestion. Quality ingredients lead to better nutrient absorption and less waste. Cats fed a poor quality diet may suffer deficiencies over time, leading to conditions like anemia, skin problems, and dental disease according to veterinarians (Source).

In summary, cheap cat food often lacks the comprehensive and balanced nutrition cats need to thrive. Regularly feeding high quality, species-appropriate cat food can help prevent many feline health issues and support longer, healthier lives.

Environmental Considerations

The environmental impact of cat food ingredients is an important consideration, especially for ethically minded pet owners. Cheaper cat foods often contain meat meals sourced from factory farms that use unsustainable practices and poor animal welfare standards. Premium brands are more likely to source natural, free-range, antibiotic-free meats from reputable suppliers [1].

Many premium cat foods also use sustainably harvested or organic fruits, vegetables, and grains. For example, Open Farm cat foods follow sustainable agriculture practices and aim for minimal environmental impact [2]. Some premium brands also offset their carbon emissions or use eco-friendly packaging. Cheaper brands are less likely to prioritize environmental factors in their supply chain or production.

Ultimately, pet owners must weigh up the higher costs of ethically sourced ingredients against environmental benefits. While premium brands cost more, their ethical sourcing practices may better align with the values of environmentally conscious cat owners.


In summary, while inexpensive cat foods can provide adequate nutrition, premium brands offer high-quality ingredients, optimized nutrition profiles, better palatability, and often better health outcomes. Key differences include:

  • Ingredient quality – Premium foods use more natural, whole ingredients while cheaper foods rely on by-products and fillers.
  • Nutrition – More expensive foods have protein rich meat as the first ingredient and optimal protein/fat ratios.
  • Manufacturing – Premium brands follow higher safety and quality standards.
  • Texture and taste – More natural ingredients lead to better palatability.
  • Health impacts – Evidence suggests premium foods reduce chronic issues like diabetes and UTIs.

Pet owners should consult with their veterinarian, factor in their cat’s health conditions, and aim for the highest quality food they can reasonably afford. While expensive does not always mean better, quality ingredients and nutrition do impact long-term health. In the end, paying a little more for premium cat food can save on vet bills and provide intangible benefits of better health and happiness.

Scroll to Top